Singapore, High Court, 8 February 2021, Syed Suhail bin Syed Zin v Attorney-General [2021] SGHC 31
Case overview
Country
Case ID
Decision date
Deciding body (English)
Type of body
Type of Court (material scope)
Type of jurisdiction
Type of Court (territorial scope)
Instance
Area
Further areas addressed
- Procedural law
- Scope of powers of public authorities (legislative, executive etc.)
Outcome of the decision
Link to the full text of the decision
General Summary
The Appellant, a Singaporean prisoner awaiting capital punishment for drug trafficking, was granted leave by the Court of Appeal (the apex court of Singapore) to commence judicial review proceedings. He accordingly filed this application. He contended that insofar as the government had scheduled the execution of his death sentence (him being a Singaporean) while imposing a moratorium on the execution of capital punishment on non-Singaporeans due to the COVID-19 pandemic, he was subject to discriminatory treatment on the basis of nationality, in violation of Article 12 of the Constitution of Singapore.
Facts of the case
In 2015, the Appellant had been convicted and sentenced to the mandatory death penalty for drug trafficking under the Misuse of Drugs Act (Cap 185, 2008 Rev Ed). Following his conviction and sentencing, the Appellant sought (1) an appeal against his conviction and sentence (which was rejected by the Court of Appeal); (2) a petition for clemency (which was rejected by the President of the Republic of Singapore); and (3) a separate application for judicial review regarding an alleged unlawful method of execution (which had been resolved).
Subsequently, on 8 Sep 2020, the President issued a new order for the Appellant’s execution on 18 Sep 2020.
The Appellant then sought leave to apply for a prohibiting order for the stay of his execution on 17 Sep 2020, which was dismissed by the High Court. He subsequently appealed against the dismissal of this application and also obtained leave to commence judicial review proceedings on the basis that the scheduling of his execution ostensibly ahead of other non-Singaporean prisoners similarly awaiting capital punishment violated Art 12 of the Constitution of Singapore (the “Constitution”).
Type of measure challenged
Measures, actions, remedies claimed
Individual / collective enforcement
Nature of the parties
Claimant(s)
Private individualDefendant(s)
Public
Type of procedure
Reasoning of the deciding body
The Appellant had not adduced any evidence to show a prima facie breach of his right to equal protection under Article 12(1) (at [58]). The Appellant had only cited one example of a non-Singaporean, Datchinamurthy, to support his case. However, the Appellant and Datchinamurthy’s cases were not similar or equally situated. In Datchinamurthy’s case, he had a realistic expectation that his case would be reviewed and potentially reopened on its merits; the Appellant did not have any such expectation since he had already unsuccessfully attempted to do so earlier (at [35]) and exhausted all options. Thus, the burden did not shift to the government to explain any differential treatment, nor did the Court have to ascertain whether the reasons for such differential treatment were legitimate.
Nevertheless, the Court opined in obiter that if the COVID-19 situation had in fact been considered by the State as a factor in the scheduling of executions on the presumption that the pandemic had affected the prisoners’ access to their families and/or posed difficulties to the repatriation of mortal remains, this factor would not amount to a legitimate reason to justify differential treatment between Singaporeans and non-Singaporeans on the scheduling of executions and would thus amount to a violation of Art 12 of the Constitution (at [62]).
If COVID 19 restrictions were a factor in scheduling or had caused scheduled executions to be postponed, this could bring about a situation where most or all Singaporeans on death row would be executed first because all their family members were in Singapore, effectively amounting to discrimination on the basis of nationality, a factor which bore no rational relation to the scheduling of executions (at [66]) and was expressly prohibited as a basis of discrimination under Art 12(2) of the Constitution (at [70]).
Conclusions of the deciding body
The application was dismissed. The Appellant was unable to show whether on the basis of the sequence of execution or nationality arguments, that his rights under Art 12 of the Constitution had been infringed.
Fundamental Right(s) involved
- Prisoners’ rights
- Right to access to justice, to a fair trial and to jury trial
Fundamental Right(s) instruments (constitutional provisions, international conventions and treaties)
General principle applied
- Rule of law
- Equality
- Non-discrimination
- Reasonableness
Balancing techniques and principles (proportionality, reasonableness, others)
In considering whether the scheduling of the Appellant’s execution had breached Art 12(1) of the Constitution, the Court considered (1) whether it resulted in the appellant being treated differently from other equally situated persons; and (2) whether this differential treatment was reasonable in that it was based on legitimate reasons.
Although the court found that limb (2) was not an issue that arose in the present case since limb (1) was not satisfied on the facts, it opined in obiter that COVID-19 restrictions would not amount to a legitimate reason to justify differential treatment between Singaporeans and non-Singaporeans in the scheduling of executions and thus this differential treatment would be deemed unreasonable under limb (2) (at [62]).